A few months ago, I wrote an article naming ten players I believe could be in the remaining 103 names affiliated with the A-Rod steroids controversy.
Much to the chagrin of Red Sox fans, one of the names listed was Red Sox DH David Ortiz.
The article was written February 10, and since then Ortiz has done nothing but confirm any suspicions that his better years are in the past.
In 44 games so far this year, Ortiz has compiled a .189AVG with 1HR and 18RBI.
Two weeks ago, I was prepping for an article titled “If it was anyone but David Ortiz they would have been benched already.”
Then he was benched.
One week after that I prepared an article titled, “If it was anyone but David Ortiz they would have been dropped in the lineup by now.”
Then he was dropped in the lineup.
While the Boston Red Sox nation tries to determine what is wrong with David Ortiz, no one considers the most pessimistic explanation: this might not be a slump— it might be the end.
Normally, I don’t target specific players in articles (however I did get butchered for a piece about Dwyane Wade last month). However, in the aftermath of Major League Baseball’s steroid era, I’m growing frustrated with the inability of any major media outlet to use the ‘s word’ when a player takes a turn for the worse.

Ortiz After One of His 45K So Far This Year
There seem to be basic guidelines when a player is caught with a needle in their hand (these are borrowed from a previous article I wrote about the steroid debacle).
1 – Deny, Deny, Deny — No matter what the media, player, family, trainers, dealers, celebrities, and world leaders say— you didn’t do it. Until they come out with Phelps-esque damning evidence, fight it to the end.
2 – When you admit to steroid use, do so in the most minimal time frame possible — If you tested positive in April 2003, tell the media that you tried steroids only once in your life… it just happened to be in April 2003 (and of course you never tried it again).
Just one time I would like to see a player come out and say, “Yes, I did it. I took performance enhancing drugs because I wanted to be better than everyone else, and they worked. I didn’t only try it once and get unlucky, and I didn’t take something my trainer gave me without knowing what it was. I read the label, ingredients, and directions, then popped the needle in and played a whole lot better than I had before. If I hadn’t been caught I would have never come clean, but now that I have I may as well tell the truth.”
Is that too much to ask?
This article isn’t saying that only Ortiz should do this. In truth, I wish every player who used PEDs in their prime would admit it, but that’s just a pipe dream from an increasingly pessimistic baseball fan.
Instead, this article is to point out one of the many non-productive ex-steroid users who is still siphoning an A-List contract from his team.
Anyone can tell that the writing is on the wall. Consider the following:
- The stats. David Ortiz seems to have magically lost any hint of power he ever possessed. Compare his batting average, home runs, runs batted in, slugging percentage, etc. and you will find a severe drop-off in the past few years. Yes, the same years that Major League Baseball began a strict crackdown on steroid use…
- Lou Merloni, who played with the Red Sox from 1998-2002, recently told the press how the Red Sox team doctor gave detailed explanations of how to use steroids at official team meetings. If you don’t believe me, read the story.
- David Ortiz’s former Bash Brother (no steroid reference intended) recently tested positive for a drug commonly used while cycling off of steroids. Translation: the only reason on God’s green earth he would be using this drug would be to cycle off of steroids.
Once again, this article isn’t meant to condemn only David Ortiz.
However, in a half-joking-half-serious manner, Ortiz has to know that the show is over.
It’s just time to come clean…
sk.
True.
Yeah, you can’t really say any player is clean these days! I’m not really shocked when I find out another player is using PED’s… Personally, from a pure fan perspective, I’d rather have them using them. I know it might be rough for those borderline guys to make it, but why not let them run wild again. It had me pretty entertained in the 90′s and early half of this decade! check out our sports blog http://doin-work.com
While I agree with almost 100% of this article… I honestly don’t know that steroids are the main blame for the increase/decrease in batting average. Sure home runs help the batting average, but do you think he strikes out more now b/c he’s not on steroids? I’m honestly curious.
Ortiz’s career K-Rate is 21.2%
This year’s K-Rate is 27.2%
While I don’t think steroids can be completely responsible, you never know how much is mentality at the plate is affected by not being able to drive the ball anywhere on the field.
Also, consider that in his first significant season (1998) his K-Rate was just over 26%, so this could be a sign of serious regression.
Who knows, it seems that these are the most probable possibilities:
1 – Ortiz’s complete loss of power (his XBH% has dropped from around 50% over the past three seasons to 42% this year) and hitting (the dropoff in batting average is worse) could have completely wrecked Ortiz’s mindset at the plate, making him less confident, and thus more vulnerable to strikeouts.
2 – Ortiz’s age could be leading to a regression of baseball skills, meaning that he is reverting to his early days (and the aforementioned 1998 K-Rate)
Basically, No.1 is the steroids possibility and No.2 is the natural reversion possibility.
What do you think?
sk.
First of all, great research, I appreciate it!
Secondly… I don’t know. I’m sure not hitting leads to a worse mentality and therefore worse hitting which leads to worse mentality, etc. They used to always say in golf “it only took one” to make the bad streak and thoughts that came with it go away. Maybe that’s true for him, maybe not.
While I do think he probably used he’s got to be a little “country strong” like Ryan Howard. I mean those guys just swing for the fences. (adam dunn, etc) However, I do think it plays some impact on his batting average, but not nearly as much as it does on his power numbers.
I’m getting ripped up for this piece over on Bleacher Report, I even had to add a disclaimer at the bottom saying “I never asserted that this is fact.”
Yikes, you should check it out.
sk.
wow… you really are… sheesh
If you’re not getting ripped you’re not doing your job.
In the blog world maybe that’s true willie… but that’s not how life goes at my office
Everything is opposite on the internet! It’s like an episode of Lost.
Lost reference… +1 for big willie